AIF Fund Governance: Managing Conflicts of Interest and Related-Party Transactions

AIF Fund Governance

When investing into an Alternative Investment Fund (AIF), you would expect decisions being made by the fund manager in the best interest of investors. However, you may later find out that the fund has invested in an entity that is connected to the fund sponsor. AIF Fund Governance will help to manage and prevent conflicts of interest by having clear policies, transparency and ensuring independent decisions are made. Businesses looking for AIF registration in India should understand what responsibilities they have. 

How Do AIFs Manage Conflicts of Interest? 

AIFs will manage conflicts of interest by identifying, disclosing and having clear processes to approve any conflicts. Fund managers will act as fiduciaries for investors under SEBI. Generally, this will include: 

  • Conflict of interest policies. 
  • Disclosure of any connected parties. 
  • Investor approval where applicable. 
  • Independent review of sensitive transactions. 
  • Well documented investment decisions. 
  • Monitoring compliance. 

Ultimately, this will reduce the likelihood of conflicts of interest influencing decisions. 

What is AIF Fund Governance? 

An Alternative Investment Fund will take pooled funds from investors and invest according to a strategy. 

Fund managers will be making decisions using other peoples’ money, so it is important they have good governance. This will ensure decisions are made with a clear process, with approvals and accountability. 

Why having good governance? 

Having good governance will build trust between investors and fund managers. 

You may understand that fund managers will run multiple investment schemes, but you would want to know that there isn’t any preferential treatment. 

Having clear governance processes will help to address concerns and allow long term operation of the fund. 

What are common conflicts of interest for an AIF? 

Conflicts of interest occur when there may be a personal, financial or business connection that could influence fund manager decisions. 

Not all conflicts of interest will result in any wrongdoing however failing to identify potential issues can cause major problems. 

Conflicts of Interest between Fund Managers and Investors 

There may be a financial interest in the business the fund is looking to invest in. This will create a potential conflict of interest for the fund manager. Other examples could be: 

  • Investing in connected companies. 
  • Undisclosed fees from investee companies. 
  • Providing preferential opportunities to certain investors. 
  • Decisions being made due to personal connections. 

Appropriate disclosure will be required. 

Conflicts of Interest between Funds 

Some fund managers manage multiple AIF schemes. If two schemes want to invest in the same company, how should the investment be split? 

Without a clear process to determine how to allocate investments, one fund may get preferential treatment. 

Fund managers should have clear processes in place to ensure investments are fairly allocated and transactions between schemes are handled appropriately. 

Understanding AIF Related-Party Transactions 

AIF related-party transactions involve dealings with parties connected to the fund, its manager, sponsor or other relevant persons. 

Although, this isn’t always prohibited, they need to be carefully considered as connected parties may influence the price, choice of investments or commercial terms. Common examples of related party transactions could be: 

  • Investing in an associate. 
  • Buying securities from a connected party. 
  • Selling investments to another scheme under the same fund manager. 
  • Using services from an associate. 

If an AIF buys securities held by another fund under the same organisation, the transaction should be considered to ensure it is fair and the correct approvals have been obtained. 

SEBI Regulations 

AIFs are regulated by SEBI under the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012 and relevant circulars. 

Conflict of interest is covered under regulation 21. This requires fund managers to have written policies in place to identify, monitor and mitigate conflicts. 

There are requirements for disclosure to investors, restrictions on investments and dealing with connected entities. 

Disclosures & Approvals 

Certain investments into associates and related party transactions will require approval from investors holding at least 75% of the value of investments. There may also be additional voting restrictions for certain transactions involving significant investors. 

Fund managers should be clear on what type of transaction it is. A general statement may not be enough as there may be a requirement for specific approvals. 

Investment Committees 

Investment committees can help funds to consider transactions and identify any potential conflicts of interest. 

They may have responsibilities such as: 

  • Reviewing investment proposals. 
  • Questioning valuations. 
  • Reviewing connections between parties. 

If a member of the committee has a personal interest, then the fund should consider appropriate disclosure and recusal. Good practices could include: 

  • Declaration of personal interests. 
  • Minutes of meetings. 
  • Reviewing documentation. 
  • Identifying related parties. 
  • Recording investment decisions. 

The committee should have appropriate powers and responsibilities under the relevant AIF framework and fund documentation. 

Valuation & Fees 

Valuation can cause conflicts of interest. If the investments aren’t traded on the market then a higher valuation can affect how the fund performs and depending on the fee structure, can also affect the fund manager financially. Fees can also cause concerns if services are being provided by associated entities. 

Fund managers should have appropriate valuation processes and disclose any relevant fees. Independent valuations should be in place if required. 

Good Internal Processes 

Having a strong AIF Fund Governance process means having clear processes for staff to follow. 

The policy should detail how potential conflicts of interest are identified, reported, reviewed and resolved. For example, investment professionals may be required to declare any connections to the investee company before approval. Key things to include in your policy: 

  • Identify connected parties. 
  • Declare staff conflicts of interest. 
  • Approval processes for investments. 
  • Review related party transactions. 
  • Recusal. 
  • Keeping records. 
  • Periodic compliance reviews. 

Having a written policy will only be useful if it is consistently followed. 

Transparency and AIF Investor Protection 

Investors need sufficient information to understand how their capital is being managed. AIF investor protection involves transparent disclosures, fair treatment and adherence to applicable investment terms. 

SEBI’s framework includes requirements relating to periodic disclosures of relevant financial, operational, risk and transactional information. Investors should also receive applicable information about fees and material conflicts. 

For effective AIF fund compliance, managers should review their disclosure practices alongside the placement memorandum and governing documents. 

Common Errors 

Even experienced investment teams can face issues with governance if there aren’t clear processes in place. Common errors include: 

  • Failure to identify connected parties. 
  • Assuming all conflicts of interest are acceptable once disclosed. 
  • Failure to obtain the required investor approvals. 
  • Inconsistent valuation processes. 
  • Incomplete minutes from the committee. 
  • Failure to consider fees paid to associates. 
  • Failure to update conflict of interest policies. 

For example, getting a few investors to agree informally may not meet the formal voting requirements. Having the right documentation is key. 

Best Practice for Good AIF Fund Governance 

Good governance should be part of normal fund management. By taking simple steps, fund managers can improve their processes. 

  • Identify connections – Keep up to date records of associates and connected parties. 
  • Review transactions – Review potential conflicts before approving investments. 
  • Document decisions – Document reasons for important investment decisions. 
  • Approvals – Follow the relevant investor approval processes. 
  • Be transparent – Ensure you are providing the required disclosures accurately and on time. 
  • Update policies – Update your internal processes to reflect any changes in regulations or fund activity. 

Regular training can help investment and compliance teams to identify conflicts early. 

FAQs:

Are related party transactions prohibited? 

No. Certain transactions can be undertaken but will have relevant restrictions, disclosures and approvals from investors. 

What is a conflict of interest for an AIF? 

A conflict of interest occurs when there may be a personal or business interest that could influence decisions being made on behalf of investors. 

Do AIFs require investor approvals for related party transactions?

Certain specific transactions will require approval from investors holding at least 75% of the value of investments. This will depend on what type of transaction it is. 

Who is responsible for managing conflicts of interest? 

The fund manager and sponsor have key responsibilities under regulation. Compliance staff and investment committees may also support. 

Why is independent valuation important? 

Independent valuations can help reduce concerns that assets are being valued unfairly and can provide more reliable reporting to investors. 

Can an AIF manager manage multiple funds? 

Yes, however they need to consider potential conflicts between schemes and follow relevant rules to ensure investments are fairly allocated or assets transferred. 

Conclusion 

Having a strong AIF Fund Governance process will help protect investors. Conflicts of interest and related party transactions may occur as part of normal investment activity but having clear policies, transparency and appropriate approvals will help to minimise risks. Fund managers should regularly review their governance processes to ensure decisions are following relevant SEBI requirements. Businesses looking to set up an alternative investment fund may want to consider using an AIF registration consultant in India to understand what requirements they have for registration, governance and compliance.